296 printings
Gus Zernial
Monte Irvin
Gold
Monte Irvin
Hank Sauer
Gold
Hank Sauer
Ed Lopat
Gold
Ed Lopat
James Edward Runnels
Gold
Pete Runnels
Ted Kluszewski
Bobby Young
Harvey Haddix
Gold
Harvey Haddix
Jackie Robinson
Gold
Jackie Robinson
Paul Smith
Billy Martin
Gold
Billy Martin
Preacher Roe
Gold
Al Rosen
Vic Janowicz
Phil Rizzuto
Gold
Phil Rizzuto
Walt Dropo
Johnny Lipon
Johnny Lipon
Gold
Warren Spahn
Warren Spahn
Gold
Bobby Shantz
Luke Easter
Granny Hamner
Harvey Kuenn
Ray Jablonski
Ferris Fain
Paul Minner
Jim Hegan
Ed Mathews
John Klippstein
Duke Snider
Johnny Schmidtz
Manuel Rivera
Junior Gilliam
Gold
Junior Gilliam
Hoyt Wilhelm
Gold
Hoyt Wilhelm
Whitey Ford
Eddie Stanky
Sherm Lollar
Mel Parnell
Willie Jones
Don Mueller
Dick Groat
Ned Garver
Richie Ashburn
Gold
Richie Ashburn
Ken Raffensberger
Ellis Kinder
Billy Hunter
Ray Murray
Yogi Berra
Gold