624 printings
Josh Bell
Black
Scott Podsednik
Black
Scott Podsednik
Mark Kotsay
Black
Mark Kotsay
Brandon Phillips Martin Prado
Joe Saunders
Robinson Cano
Black
Robinson Cano
Robinson Cano
All-Black
Gabe Kapler
Brendan Harris
Matt Downs
Gold
Matt Downs
Matt Downs
Black
Jose Tabata
Matt Daley
Gold
Matt Daley
Matt Daley
Black
Jhan Marinez
Black
Mark Ellis
Gabe Gross
Adrian Gonzalez
Joey Votto
Black
Joey Votto
Joey Votto
All-Black
Joey Votto
Gold
Shelley Duncan
Gold
Shelley Duncan
All-Black
Shelley Duncan
Mike Redmond
Placido Polanco
Black
Placido Polanco
LaTroy Hawkins
LaTroy Hawkins
Gold
Nick Swisher
Matt Harrison
Rafael Soriano
Rafael Soriano
Gold
Miguel Cabrera
Gold
Miguel Cabrera
Miguel Cabrera
Jake Arrieta
SP
Jake Arrieta
All-Black
Jake Arrieta
Gold
Jake Arrieta
Jake Arrieta
Black
Jim Thome
Jim Thome
Black
Jim Thome
Gold
Mike Minor
Gold
Mike Minor
Chris Perez
Joel Hanrahan
Gold
Joel Hanrahan
Dana Eveland
Yadier Molina
Gold
Yadier Molina
Yadier Molina
Black
Brooklyn Dodgers