196 printings
Ted Williams
Amethyst
Edwin Encarnacion
Amethyst
Don Mattingly
Amber
Don Mattingly
Emerald
Anthony Rizzo
Onyx
Joe DiMaggio
Jose Altuve
Jose Altuve
Sapphire
Jose Altuve
Gold
Jose Fernandez
Joe Mauer
Sapphire
Joe Mauer
Carlos Gonzalez
Bryce Harper
Bryce Harper
Amber
Cole Hamels
Amethyst
Mike Piazza
Amber
Mike Piazza
Mike Piazza
Emerald
Adam Wainwright
Emerald
Adam Wainwright
Dave Winfield
Amethyst
Dave Winfield
Gold
Jason Heyward
Sapphire
Albert Pujols
Onyx
Albert Pujols
Sapphire
Albert Pujols
Amethyst
Albert Pujols
Gold
Masahiro Tanaka
Sapphire
Masahiro Tanaka
Amethyst
Steve Carlton
Ruby
Steve Carlton
David Ortiz
David Ortiz
Sapphire
David Ortiz
Emerald
Jacob deGrom
Gold
Mariano Rivera
Amethyst
Mariano Rivera
Emerald
Lou Gehrig
Sapphire
Lou Gehrig
Freddie Freeman
Emerald
Freddie Freeman
Sapphire
Freddie Freeman
Randy Johnson
Amethyst
Felix Hernandez
Amethyst
Chase Utley
Stan Musial
Sapphire
Stan Musial
Emerald
Stan Musial
Bo Jackson
Onyx
Bo Jackson
Gold
Bo Jackson
Andrew McCutchen
Onyx
Andrew McCutchen
Amethyst
Andrew McCutchen
Sapphire
Craig Biggio
Sapphire
Craig Biggio
Gregory Polanco
Ruby
Satchel Paige
Sapphire
Satchel Paige
Gold