323 printings
Ken Griffey Jr
Roy Campanella
Jeff Samardzija
Lance Berkman
Brad Lidge
Will Venable
Mike Lowell
Miguel Cabrera
CC Sabathia
Daniel Bard
Garret Anderson
Grady Sizemore
Yovani Gallardo
James Shields
Christy Mathewson
Mark Buehrle
Joakim Soria
Kyle Blanks
Kris Medlen
Milton Bradley
Miguel Tejada
Daric Barton
Ricky Romero
Felix Pie
Huston Street
Mariano Rivera
Ryan Zimmerman
Tim Hudson
Bronze
Tim Hudson
Francisco Cordero
Ryan Braun
Akinori Iwamura
Johnny Mize
A.J. Pierzynski
Alex Gordon
Nate McLouth
Aaron Bates
Jason Varitek
Andrew Miller
Johnny Damon
Tommy Hanson
Aubrey Huff
Ryan Garko
Ryan Garko
Bronze
Carlos Delgado
Josh Hamilton
Jered Weaver
Aaron Poreda
Russell Martin
Matt Cain
Lou Gehrig
Aramis Ramirez
Brian Bannister
Colby Rasmus
Justin Masterson
Justin Verlander
Andy Pettitte
David Freese
Casey Kotchman
Bronze
Casey Kotchman